A hedge fund that holds a stock on March 31 has until May 15 to report it. Its next report is due on August 14. An investor who copies the filing on the day it appears holds the fund's March 31 portfolio until mid-August, when those positions are 136 days old. A fund that turns over its portfolio once a year has replaced about a third of them by then.

13F cloning is the strategy of buying the stocks that hedge funds report on Form 13F, usually their largest or most widely shared positions, and rebalancing each quarter when new filings appear. Measured results range from no significant stock-picking edge after 2008 to a lead of 3.80 percentage points a year over the S&P 500, depending on which managers are copied and over which years. Finding and reading a filing is covered in our guide to 13F and 13D filings.

What a 13F clone copies, and what it leaves out

A manager files Form 13F once it has discretion over 100 million dollars of Section 13(f) securities. The official list of those securities is made up mostly of US exchange-traded stocks, ETFs and closed-end funds, with some convertible bonds, listed options and warrants. Several kinds of position never reach the form:

  • Short positions. Managers leave them out, and they report each long position in full without subtracting a short in the same stock.
  • Options the manager wrote. Options it bought do appear, under the name and share count of the underlying stock, with PUT or CALL in a separate column. A copier who skips that column buys the shares behind a bearish put.
  • Foreign-listed shares, bonds, swaps and cash. At the end of 2024 Berkshire Hathaway held 23.5 billion dollars of five Japanese trading companies, financed in part with yen borrowing. Neither the Tokyo-listed shares nor the debt belong on a 13F.
  • Positions filed under confidential treatment. The SEC can let a manager disclose a holding late through an amended filing. Hedge fund holdings disclosed that way outperformed for up to twelve months, and a clone built from the original filing does not hold them.

For a long/short equity fund, the 13F shows one side of each pair trade. For a macro or credit fund, whose positions sit mostly in futures, bonds and swaps, it can show a small fraction of the portfolio. Monthly reporting of short positions on Form SHO was adopted in 2023, and its first filings have been postponed to February 14, 2028.

The 45-day lag, counted in days

Filers have 45 days after each quarter end. Across 14 years of filings, the average filer took 37 days, and 30% waited the full 45 days or longer. Delays followed fund flows and shareholder votes, and the risk of being copied did not explain them.

A clone that buys on each filing deadline and holds until the next one owns positions of the following ages:

Positions as ofFiling deadlineHeld untilAge of the positions while held
March 31May 15August 1445 to 136 days
June 30August 14November 1445 to 137 days
September 30November 14February 1445 to 137 days
December 31February 14May 1545 to 135 days

Deadlines falling on a weekend or holiday move to the next business day, which adds a day or two.

How much of the copied portfolio is still in place depends on the manager's turnover. A fund that replaces its whole portfolio once a year, at an even pace, has changed about 12% of it by the filing deadline and about 37% by the next one. Clone products trade heavily too: the Goldman Sachs Hedge Industry VIP ETF, which rebuilds its list from new filings every quarter, turned over 137% of its portfolio in the year to August 2025.

Positions held for years survive the delay intact. The cloning study with the strongest result kept only managers with long holding periods.

What studies of 13F cloning found

The research splits on two questions: whether hedge funds pick stocks well, and whether that skill survives the delay and the years since 2008.

Griffin and Xu compared the 13F holdings of hedge funds with those of mutual funds. Hedge funds were better stock pickers by only 1.32% a year on a value-weighted basis, and the difference was insignificant with equal weights or against price-to-sales benchmarks. Hedge funds showed no ability to time sectors or pick better styles.

Amir-Ghassemi, Papanicolaou and Perlow followed nearly 1,500 hedge funds from 1999 to 2018. The gross alpha of their 13F stock picks fell from a significant 17 basis points a month before the 2008 crisis to an insignificant 5 basis points after it. Seventeen basis points a month is about 2% a year, before the fund's fees.

Schroeder built clones of more than 150,000 portfolios from 2013 to 2023 and rebalanced them on each filing date. On nine of twelve measures the clones matched the original funds, the losers as closely as the winners. Volatility, maximum drawdown and tracking error were where they differed.

Angelini, Iqbal and Jivraj used holdings data from Novus for May 2004 to June 2019. They kept equity hedge funds with long holding periods, selected stocks that made up more than 7.5% of a manager's 13F portfolio, ranked them by how many such managers held them and bought the top 50, 47 days after each quarter end. That portfolio beat the S&P 500 total return index by 3.80% a year, with a Sharpe ratio of 0.75. The same method applied to all other hedge funds returned 10% a year and trailed the index by 0.34 points.

Clones in the Schroeder sample tracked losing funds as closely as winning ones. The filters behind the 3.80-point lead, long holding periods and concentrated stakes, are close to the ones the clone ETFs apply.

Best-ideas portfolios

A best-ideas portfolio keeps only each manager's highest-conviction positions, measured by how far a stock's weight exceeds what a diversified portfolio would hold. Among mutual fund managers, the stock with the most conviction beat the market and the rest of the same manager's holdings by 39 to 127 basis points a month, depending on the benchmark.

Hedge funds give weaker evidence. Across the 1999 to 2018 sample of nearly 1,500 funds, managers' best ideas showed no significant difference in alpha from the rest of their portfolios. In the 2004 to 2019 study, the gain from raising the conviction threshold flattened beyond a 5% portfolio weight.

Hedge fund clone ETFs and their record

Two US ETFs built on hedge fund 13F filings have records longer than five years. Both rebuild their portfolios each quarter after the filing deadline and weight their stocks equally.

Global X Guru Index ETF (GURU)
Tracks the Solactive Guru Index, which takes the single largest 13F position of each selected hedge fund. Funds need at least 500 million dollars of reported holdings, low turnover and a concentrated top holding. The index had 78 stocks at the end of 2025, and the fund charges 0.75% a year.
Goldman Sachs Hedge Industry VIP ETF (GVIP)
Holds about 50 stocks that appear most often among the top ten holdings of hedge funds with 10 to 200 US stock positions and at least 10 million dollars of reported equity. It launched on November 1, 2016 and charges 0.45% a year.
Fund or indexPeriod ending1 year5 years, a yearLongest period, a year
GURUDecember 202525.27%7.56%11.03% over 10 years
S&P 500December 202517.88%14.42%14.82% over 10 years
GVIPAugust 202523.80%12.80%15.96% since November 2016
S&P 500August 202515.88%14.73%15.45% since November 2016

GURU beat the S&P 500 by 7.4 points in 2025 and trailed it by 3.8 points a year over ten years. GVIP finished half a point a year ahead from its launch to August 2025, and its worst quarter, the three months to June 2022, was a loss of 23.65%.

Other clone ETFs have closed. The AlphaClone Alternative Alpha ETF, another fund built on hedge fund 13F filings, was liquidated on August 31, 2022. ETFs that copy hedge fund returns with futures and index exposures, instead of their stock lists, are compared in our guide to investing in hedge funds with little money.

How a do-it-yourself 13F clone is put together

Building the portfolio directly costs nothing but trading and taxes, and every decision the ETFs make has to be made by hand:

  1. The managers. Fundamental equity funds with concentrated, slow-moving books carry the most information in a 13F. Quantitative funds trade in and out of stocks far more often, so much of what their filing shows has changed before it is published. Our list of hedge funds by strategy sorts the best-known names.
  2. The rows. Remove every line marked PUT or CALL, and check whether a large position is new or an old stake disclosed after confidential treatment.
  3. The positions. Keep the largest holdings, such as each manager's top ten or every stake above 5% of the reported portfolio.
  4. The timing. Rebalance once the filings are out, on or after each deadline in the table above.
  5. The taxes. A position sold within a year produces a short-term gain, taxed at ordinary income rates of up to 37%, against a top long-term rate of 20%. Quarterly rebalancing in a taxable account produces short-term gains on every stock that drops out of the list within twelve months.

Investing in the hedge funds themselves, instead of copying their stocks, requires accredited investor status or a registered fund that holds them. Both routes are covered in our guide to investing in hedge funds with little money.

This article is general information, not investment advice.

Questions about copying hedge funds

Is it legal to copy hedge fund trades?

Yes. Form 13F filings are public documents on the SEC's EDGAR database, and anyone can buy the stocks they list. The limit is timing: a 13F shows long positions as of the last day of a quarter and can be filed up to 45 days later, so a copier trades on information that is weeks or months old.

Can you see what hedge funds are buying in real time?

No. The 13F is quarterly and arrives up to 45 days after the quarter ends. A Schedule 13D, filed within five business days once an investor crosses 5% of a company with intent to influence it, is faster but covers only those large stakes. Monthly reporting of short positions on Form SHO has been postponed, with first filings now due on February 14, 2028.

Which ETFs copy hedge fund stock picks?

Two established US funds run the strategy. The Global X Guru Index ETF (GURU) holds the top 13F position of selected hedge funds and charges 0.75% a year. It returned 11.03% a year over the ten years to December 2025, against 14.82% for the S&P 500. The Goldman Sachs Hedge Industry VIP ETF (GVIP) holds about 50 stocks that appear most often among hedge funds' top ten holdings and charges 0.45%. It returned 15.96% a year from its November 2016 launch to August 2025, against 15.45% for the S&P 500.

Do hedge fund stock picks beat the market?

It depends on the period and on which managers are copied. Across nearly 1,500 hedge funds, the gross alpha of their 13F stock picks fell from 17 basis points a month before 2008 to a statistically insignificant 5 basis points after. A portfolio of the highest-conviction stocks of fundamental equity hedge funds, bought 47 days after each quarter end, beat the S&P 500 by 3.80% a year from 2004 to 2019, while the same method applied to other hedge funds trailed it.