Take 10,000 dollars that will pay for a house deposit next autumn. On October 29, 2026, a 12-month CD at Capital One paid 4.00% APY, which turns the deposit into 10,400 dollars at maturity, insured by the FDIC. The iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF showed a 30-day SEC yield of 3.79% the day before, with no lock-up and no insurance. An S&P 500 ETF pays no fixed rate at all, and the index it tracks lost 18.04% in 2022, dividends included.

The ETF side of the comparison covers everything from a fund of one-month Treasury bills to a fund of stocks, so the answer depends on which ETF is meant.

A certificate of deposit (CD) is a bank deposit that pays a fixed rate for a fixed term, insured by the FDIC up to 250,000 dollars per depositor, per bank, per ownership category, with a penalty for withdrawing before maturity. An exchange-traded fund (ETF) is a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange at a market price. Its value rises and falls with whatever it holds, and it carries no deposit insurance.

CD, Treasury and money market yields at the end of October 2026

The Federal Reserve held its policy rate at 3.75% to 4.00% on October 28, 2026. Short-term Treasury yields sat above that range, and the best bank CDs sat close to them.

ProductYieldDateProtection
National average savings account0.38%Oct 19FDIC
National average 12-month CD1.76%Oct 19FDIC
Capital One 360 12-month CD4.00% APYOct 29FDIC
Ally 18-month CD4.50% APYOct 30FDIC
3-month Treasury bill4.18%Oct 29US government
1-year Treasury4.42%Oct 29US government
Schwab Government Money Fund3.62% 7-dayOct 29None
Schwab Government Money Market ETF3.69% 7-dayOct 29None
iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF3.79% SECOct 28None
iShares Core US Aggregate Bond ETF5.05% SECOct 28None

The yields are measured four different ways, so the rows do not compare exactly like for like. A CD quotes an annual percentage yield that includes compounding. Treasury yields are the government's par yields. A money market fund quotes its income over the last seven days, annualized, and a bond ETF quotes a 30-day SEC yield after fees, which looks back over the previous month.

Why the average CD pays 1.76% when some pay 4.50%

The FDIC's national rate is an average weighted by each bank's deposits, so the largest banks dominate it. On October 27, 2026, an 18-month CD paid 0.01% at Chase and 0.03% at Bank of America, against 2.00% at Citibank, 3.60% at Capital One 360, 3.65% at American Express and 4.50% at Ally, in a comparison Ally publishes for California customers. On 10,000 dollars for a year, the gap between the national average and a 4.00% CD is 224 dollars.

What FDIC insurance covers and what an ETF can lose

The FDIC insures deposits up to 250,000 dollars per depositor, per insured bank, for each account ownership category. A single account, a joint account and a retirement account at the same bank are separate categories, so one household can hold more than 250,000 dollars insured at one bank. If the bank fails, the FDIC pays back principal and interest up to the limit.

An ETF sits in a brokerage account. SIPC protects up to 500,000 dollars per customer, including 250,000 dollars of cash, when a brokerage firm fails and customer assets are missing. A fall in the market value of the ETF stays with the investor.

How far an ETF can fall depends on what it holds:

Treasury bill ETFs
The iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF had an effective duration of 0.11 years on October 29, 2026. A one percentage point rise in rates would cut its price by about 0.11%, which about six weeks of the higher income makes up. Its income falls within weeks when the Fed cuts rates.
Money market ETFs
A newer category. The Schwab Government Money Market ETF launched on June 12, 2025, trades near 100 dollars a share and floats with its holdings. Money market mutual funds seek to hold a share at 1.00 dollar and cannot guarantee it.
Core bond ETFs
The iShares Core US Aggregate Bond ETF had a duration of 5.71 years and returned minus 1.87% in the 12 months to September 30, 2026, as rates rose. In 2022 the 10-year Treasury bond lost 17.83%.
Stock ETFs
An S&P 500 ETF falls with the index: 36.55% in 2008 and 18.04% in 2022, dividends included. Our article on the 60/40 portfolio covers how stocks and bonds behaved together in past crashes.

An equity ETF is an ETF that holds stocks: the ETF is the wrapper, and equity is one of the assets it can hold.

Brokered CDs bought through a broker

Brokerage firms also sell CDs issued by banks. These brokered CDs keep FDIC insurance up to the limit at the issuing bank, and they trade differently. Instead of paying an early withdrawal penalty, the holder sells the CD to another investor in a secondary market. The broker may charge a fee, some CDs find no buyer at all, and the sale price can be lower than the purchase price, most often when rates have risen since purchase. Some brokered CDs are callable, so the bank can repay them early when rates drop.

CD early withdrawal penalties against ETF bid-ask spreads

Federal rules set only a minimum penalty: a time deposit withdrawn within six days of opening must lose at least seven days' simple interest. Each bank sets the rest:

  • Capital One 360 charges three months of interest on terms of 12 months or less, and six months of interest on longer terms.
  • Ally charges 30 days of interest on terms under three months, 60 days on terms from three to 24 months, and up to 150 days on terms of 49 months or longer. It does not allow partial withdrawals.

On a 10,000 dollar 12-month CD at 4.00%, a withdrawal after six months forfeits about 99 dollars of the roughly 198 dollars earned. On a five-year CD at 3.60% closed after one month, six months of interest comes to about 178 dollars against about 30 dollars earned, so the penalty takes roughly 149 dollars of principal. Capital One's own page says an early withdrawal is the only way to lose money in its CDs.

Selling an ETF costs the bid-ask spread. The iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF had a 30-day median spread of 0.01% at the end of October 2026, about 1 dollar for buying and selling 10,000 dollars. The real exit cost of a stock or bond ETF is the price on the day of sale, which can sit well below the purchase price. Our comparison of ETFs and mutual funds explains spreads, premiums and discounts in more detail.

How CD interest and ETF dividends are taxed

CD interest is ordinary income, taxed by the federal government and by the state. It is taxable in the year it is credited to the account and available without a substantial penalty, and on a CD that defers interest for more than a year, part of it is taxed each year as original issue discount even though nothing is paid out. An early withdrawal penalty is deductible on Schedule 1 of Form 1040.

Interest on Treasury bills, notes and bonds is exempt from state and local income tax. A fund passes that exemption on only for the share of its dividends that came from US government obligations. For 2025 that share was 95.14% for the iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF, 66.61% for the Vanguard Federal Money Market Fund and 0.31% for the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF. California, Connecticut and New York allow the exemption only if at least 50% of the fund's assets were in US government obligations at the end of each quarter.

For an investor in the 24% federal bracket who pays 5% state income tax, at the yields quoted in late October 2026:

  • The 4.00% CD keeps 4.00% × (1 − 0.24 − 0.05) = 2.84% after tax.
  • The Treasury bill ETF at 3.79%, with 95.14% of its income exempt from state tax, keeps about 2.87%.
  • The CD needs about 4.04% to match the ETF after tax. In a state without income tax, the 4.00% CD keeps 3.04% and the ETF 2.88%.

The CD's 4.00% is fixed for the year. The ETF's 3.79% moves with bill rates as its holdings roll over.

A fixed CD rate against a floating Treasury bill yield

A CD locks its rate on the day it opens. A Treasury bill ETF or money market fund rolls its holdings every few weeks, so its yield follows short-term rates in both directions. Between September 4 and October 29, 2026 the 3-month bill went from 3.91% to 4.18%, and a CD opened in early September kept its September rate. If the Fed cuts, the ETF's income falls within weeks and the CD keeps paying until maturity, after which it renews at whatever rate the bank offers then.

Consumer prices rose 3.7% in the 12 months to September 2026. At that pace a 4.00% CD pays 0.3 points more than inflation before tax and less than inflation after a 24% federal tax. A CD at the 1.76% national average pays about 1.9 points less than inflation before any tax.

Spreading money across CDs that mature in 6, 12, 18 and 24 months, a CD ladder, frees part of it every six months. Each new rung is bought at the rate of the day, so the ladder's average rate moves more slowly than a fund's yield and faster than a single long CD's.

CDs, Treasury ETFs and stock ETFs by time horizon

A known expense on a fixed date within two years
A CD maturing before the date, or a Treasury bill bought to mature then, fixes the amount in advance. Under the FDIC limit, the CD carries deposit insurance and the bill carries the US government's backing.
An emergency fund with no date
A money market fund, a Treasury bill ETF or a high-yield savings account gives access within a day or two without a penalty. Each pays a rate that floats.
Money above 250,000 dollars
Splitting deposits across banks or ownership categories keeps CDs insured. Treasury bills carry the government's backing at any amount, held directly or through a fund.
Money for ten years or more
100 dollars put into the S&P 500 at the start of 1928 grew to about 1.16 million dollars by the end of 2025 with dividends reinvested, against 2,578 dollars in 3-month Treasury bills, with the falls of 2008 and 2022 along the way. Moving a lump sum into them at once or in stages is the subject of our article on dollar-cost averaging against a lump sum.

This article is general information and does not constitute investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a 10,000 dollar CD make in one year?

At 4.00% APY, the rate Capital One paid on its 12-month CD on October 29, 2026, a 10,000 dollar CD earns 400 dollars in a year. At the national average for 12-month CDs, 1.76% in October 2026, the same deposit earns 176 dollars. The interest is taxed as ordinary income.

Are CDs safer than ETFs?

A CD at an FDIC-insured bank is insured up to 250,000 dollars per depositor, per bank, per ownership category, and its rate is fixed for the term. No ETF carries deposit insurance. A Treasury bill ETF holds short government debt and its price moves by cents, while a stock ETF can fall sharply: the S&P 500 lost 36.55% in 2008 and 18.04% in 2022, dividends included.

Can a Treasury bill ETF lose money?

Its price can dip slightly, and the yield falls when short-term rates fall. The iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF had an effective duration of 0.11 years at the end of October 2026, so a one percentage point rise in rates would move its price by roughly 0.11%. It has no deposit insurance, and its holdings are backed by the US government.

Is it smart to put 100,000 dollars in a CD?

100,000 dollars is within the 250,000 dollar FDIC limit for one depositor at one bank in one ownership category. What it earns depends on the bank: in October 2026 the national average 12-month CD paid 1.76%, while online banks paid 4.00% to 4.50%. With consumer prices up 3.7% in the 12 months to September 2026, the lower rate lost purchasing power before tax.

Are mutual funds safer than ETFs?

A mutual fund and an ETF holding the same securities carry the same market risk. The wrapper changes how you trade and how capital gains are distributed. Our comparison of ETFs and mutual funds covers those differences.